Leek and Mushroom Pie- New Vegan Recipe!

Hello subscribers/passers by!

So in the past I’ve been doing recipes for quite random things, but last night I thought I’d have a go at my first ever pie

I’ve never made a pie before, so was worried it would go completely wrong, but on the understanding that Leek and Mushroom flavours go excellently together, and knowing that a cream sauce consists of Flour, Butter and Milk, I set about blindly making this pie and I have to say it could have gone a lot worse!

The cream sauce was a perfectΒ accompanimentΒ to the leek and garlicy (we love garlic but you can put less in if you’re not such a big fan) mushroom filling, and although the pastry was rolled a little too thick, it still tasted delicious and went down a storm with my meat-eating, anti-vegan boyfriend! πŸ˜€ (He is even becoming converted to tofu now and is feeling very insecure in his meat-eating-sexuality!)

So here goes with the exact recipe of what I put in my delicious Vegan Leek and Mushroom Pie for two


Pastry, either premade or homemade is fine, homemade will ofcourse be tastier πŸ™‚

1 Leek (roughly chopped)

6 Mushrooms (roughly chopped)

2 Cloves of Garlic (chopped)

Handful of chopped chives

Cream Sauce Ingredients:

3 Tbsp Plain Flour

4 Tbsp Dairy Free Butter

Soya Milk


1. Add 1 tbsp of dairy-free butter to a pan with a splash of oil, and add the leek and mushrooms to the pan. Pre-heat oven to 200C

2. After 2 minutes add the 2 cloves of chopped garlic and continue to cook the leek/mushroom/garlic combo.

3. Whilst leaving the above on a low heat to slowly cook through, you can start making the white creamy sauce. To do this melt 3 large tbsp of butter in a pan.

4. When this has melted, take off the hob and add 3 heaped tbsp of plain flour, and mix in ensuring they aren’t separated in any way.

5. Then you can add the milk, one splash at a time until it is a thick sauce, but not too thick or it will just make the pie taste like flour (to check this just taste the sauce when you think it’s saucey enough, and if it tastes very floury add a splash more milk). If you then accidentally add too much milk I’m sure you could add more flour to balance it back out! This is one of those parts that you have to play by ear and hopefully it’ll taste yummy πŸ˜€

6.Make sure to continuously stir the leek/mushroom/garlic combo on the other hob, and when the white sauce is done you can add the chopped chives to the veggie pan for about 2 minutes.

7. Now you can roll out your pastry. I am not a pastry expert and feel I rolled mine a little too thick, so next time I’d make sure it really is very thin, but not too thin that it’ll all fall apart!

8. Coat the bottom of the pie dish (or in my case a take-out carton!) with butter to grease, then add the pastry.

9. Now pour the cream sauce into the veg pan, and mix to make sure all veg is covered by sauce. In my photos, you can see mine looks a little oily. I think this must be from the butter in the veg pan, which sort of sat on top rather than emulsifying in the sauce, but the filling tasted amazing so I wouldn’t worry about this too much.


10. Pour this creamy-veggie combo into the pie dish.

11. Roll out another piece of pastry, and place it on top of the pie, making sure you cover all the edges.

12. Pinch along the edges of the pie firmly to make sure the lid and sides do not separate when you take the pie out of the dish (like mine kinda did!).

13. Slit holes in the top of the pie to let the hot air out whilst it is cooking in the oven.

14. Place in 200 C pre-heated oven for around 30-40Β minutes. I’m still getting used to my new oven but mine took 30 minutes after I was checking it every 5 minutes with paranoia that it would burn πŸ™‚

15. Remove from oven and enjoy piping hot!

Please comment below with ideas for what I could serve this pie with in the future. It was a meal for me and my boyfriend, so to make it pretty I added a few chives in a little spiral but don’t know if there’s any side I could use?

Thanks for reading, I hope you enjoy this recipe! x


44 thoughts on “Leek and Mushroom Pie- New Vegan Recipe!

  1. Pingback: Very Cute Mini Pie « Veganism as a meat lover

  2. Helloo, keep meaning to comment on this! Made it for my Christmas dinner to replace Turkey and have made it twice since, thanks so much for the recipe!

    P.s. really enjoying stalking exactly what you eat each day this month – glad other vegans eat a lot/worry about eating a lot as I do both, a lot!

    Good luck with the rest of your exams πŸ™‚

    • Heey! Thanks so much I’m glad you enjoyed this recipe… I love it!! Yeah it’s a bit of an experiment… what was supposed to be a detox has turned into lots of confessions about snacking and beer drinking :p One day I’ll shock you all and turn into a super health freak :L

    • I know that home made and traditional puff pastry (and pretty much all pastry)is made with butter but here in Australia at least, all the commercial bought pre made pay is made with oil, predominantly canola, so is vegan…yay!

  3. I’ve been vegetarian for just under a year,I’m always on the lookout for recipes,as my creations are a bit too much ‘messing about’ (as people say)-this was beautiful

    • Thanks Jim, I’m glad you liked it, this is my favourite pie recipe! Congrats on your veggie-anniversary coming up soon πŸ˜€

  4. Thank you for this, my son is a vegan and daughter a veggie (alias I’m the only meat eater) , this pie went down a treat in my house.
    I’m always on the look out for decent meals the whole faily can enjoy

    • I’m so glad you all enjoyed it! Yes that’s a constant battle for me trying to satisfy the non-veggies (and the veggies) because nobody wants a plate of plain veg put in front of them do they! Glad you enjoyed it!

    • Sounds great, yeah pastry on top is a great idea actually, mmm all these comments are making me want to make this again!

  5. A big salad would be the perfect accompaniment to a creamy pie, balance out the lovely stodginess with lovely crispness, add some tangy sourness to contrast with the creaminess.

  6. Pingback: Vegan MoFo: Leek and Mushroom Pie | Wing It Vegan

  7. Pingback: Vegan MoFo: Leek and Mushroom Pie

  8. Just tried this and it is amazing! I was doubtful as sauce didn’t taste so good on own but once it’s cooked in with it it is heavenly! One of my favourites now, also just did a top crust thank you πŸ™‚

  9. Made this without the “pie” and substituted ground matzah meal for the flour in the sauce. Had to add lots of soy milk but the end result was amazing. It was the hit of the seder. In fact, I have to make more for tonight, because it was devoured. Thank you!

  10. Pingback: Vegan Leek and Mushroom Pie – Rescuer's Heart For Animals

  11. Pingback: 25 vegan Christmas recipe ideas for your first vegan Christmas! - Jade's A Mermaid

  12. Pingback: Cooking with leeks | Pastry & purls

  13. This was lovely! Here in the UK vegan margarine is largely crap, so I substituted it with 4 tablespoons of sunflower oil.

    • Yes I agree, that is a good idea. How did it work out with oil? I am trying to find replacements for using margarine but always just find it so convenient. Thanks for posting this comment I’m sure it’ll help others too πŸ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s